Elms Lesters Painting Rooms: The Book(s)


Elms Lesters Painting Rooms book, designed by Iain Cadby, is limited to just 1000 copies and comes in a numbered box

Eliza Williams’ feature in the current (February) issue of Creative Review takes a look at London’s Elms Lesters gallery, which regularly exhibits works by artists who learnt their trade on the streets. Recent exhibitions in the central London space have shown work by the likes of Adam Neate, Phil Frost, Futura, José Parlá, Mark Dean Veca, Stash, WK Interact, Delta and Space Invader.

Paul Jones and Fiona McKinnon, the duo that run Elms Lesters galllery, have been working closely with graphic designer Iain Cadby, of Worlds studio, for the past two years. Cadby has designed the just-launched 502-page Elms Lesters Painting Rooms book which celebrates the gallery’s 25th anniversary by cataloguing 17 exhibitions from the last 12 years. And Cadby has also been designing the gallery’s exhibition catalogues for the last year. Read on for CR’s interview with Cadby about his work with the gallery…

The Elms Lesters Painting Rooms book, limited to just 1,000 copies, is a lavish affair: it comes packaged in a white, individually numbered screen­printed box. Removal of the dustjacket reveals an irrides­cent hardback cover, blind embossed, with iconography pertaining to the gallery and its artists.

Within the book, the chronological cataloguing of various events is split into sections by smaller pages which serve to make the chapter divisions more evident. Interviews with the various artists also sit on smaller pages within the book, employing different stocks and coloured inks.

Creative Review: Tell us about your relationship with Elms Lesters – you’re a big fan of the gallery aren’t you?
Iain Cadby: I can’t remember how I heard of it or when I first went there but it must be about nine years ago. Seeing things like Delta’s work in there was amazing. Having known his work for about 20 years – to see it in the flesh and to have the opportunity to potentially buy and own a piece of that artwork endeared me to the gallery.

My relationship with Paul and Fiona was born out of a mutual love of the work, especially the graf guys. My love was primarily for Futura and Delta – and Paul is a huge fan of all the artists – but you don’t really get bigger fans of Delta than me and Paul. I guess I was going there a lot and trying to spend as much time there as I could – for me it was like hanging out in the British Museum – it was just nice to be in that space. Then I became a client – I was buying pieces from the gallery.

CR: So how did you end up working with the gallery on these books
IC: Paul and Fiona were round my house putting up a work by Delta and I was showing them some of my work and they said “Hey do you want to do a book on the gallery?”. I was like “Yeah, I’d love to.”

CR: Tell us about the book…
IC: It’s been a true labour of love for all of us: almost two years, in fact, culminating in 11 days in Italy printing on two KBA presses… We ended up printing on irridescent paper for the hard cover which is blind debossed… I created various graphic elements from the gallery’s artists’ work – the cover is meant to be an expression of the gallery. So yes, Fiona and I have spent a huge amount of time collating all the work – there’s over 500 image – working out all the right people to write it from an art historical point of view, the right person to write the introduction about the gallery and the history of the area and the gallery. The book is arranged chronologically because you need the story to be clear…

Within the book, there are smaller sized dividers to help separate the shows and then also smaller pages that contain interviews with the artists. These pages are not only smaller than the other pages – but they utilise different stocks and colours and sometimes printing up to eight colours which is fairly rare, I’d imagine. On some of the intro pages there’s eight colours going on. One of the sheets we did was completely outrageous – there was 15 colours.

CR: Since starting work on the gallery book, you’ve also designed various catalogues for the shows in the space during 2008 – talk us through your approach
IC: The only thing each of the catalogues have in common is the size / format – every one I’ve done is very different – and each is inspired by the work of the artists that appears in the books. Each is very much my interpretation of the expression of the artists in the book. It’s also an expression of the excitement that I feel from these guys.

IC: The cover of the Adam & Ron Show book [May 2-31, 2008] is purposefully beautiful-ugly. It’s meant to be garish. It’s meant to be gameshow-meets-horror-film-meets-Metallica-meets-McDonalds. Ron’s work is very darkly ironic and deeply subversive and Adam’s work has this British urban angst, so the cover is trying to communicate some of those things. The cover is always the most important part in delivering the essence of what it is. And the introduction of each catalogue has a different aesthetic which carries on the language introduced in the cover.

In the Adam & Ron Show catalogue, the intro came from a nice letter which Adam had written to Ron, many years ago, saying how much he admired his work, and Ron wrote back in his typical way with a gag basically – next time you’re giving away free art – let me know before so I can grab one! This started an email dialogue between them which is light but revealing at the same time, so I created what is in essence a sort of email language between them, hiding in lots of references to both of their artworks and also lots of symbols relating to their work and even some Portuguese – because Adam lives in Brazil and a lot of the cardboard he works with has Portugeuse text on it – and other iconography relating to their work…

CR: The colours are really vibrant in the intro, have you used any special print processes here?
IC: Normally you print in four colours (CMYK) on white paper – I think when you first start out making work – maybe when you’re at college and you start doing your first couple of print jobs you normally have one or two colours to play with and the trick with two colours is to try and make it look like three colours – so there’s a little bit of that. Although this is much more subtle. Looking this you’d probably think it’s been printed with just two colours – but in fact there’s three colours – so these are tri-tones. This isn’t anything outrageous print-wise, but tri-tones are just an interesting thing you don’t get to use very often. Three colours and the curve from zero to a hundred of each colour – has to be on a curve and the curves can’t clash otherwise you get that moiré effect. What IS interesting is I often – almost always when working on these projects – do a scatterproof. A scatterproof is a wonderful thing – I first saw one when I was working at Why Not Associates – they had drawers full of these things – I couldn’t believe them – you test what you want to do in many different ways and these are all printed on a sheet. Then you can look at all these and choose the ones which work the best.

So I did scatterproofs for this catalogue… There’s tri tones and a metallic – on orange paper and on white – and you print various versions of the same thing but with slightly varied colours to see what will look the best. Scatterproofs – printed on the press that will produce the books – are brilliant. It’s an amazing way, it’s the only way, when you’re doing experimental stuff, to know what you’re dealing with.

CR: And the Delta catalogue [June 1-30, 2008] also looks like there’s some nifty print processes going on…

IC: Fairly intense this one – I redrew elements of Boris’ work so I could use these graphics as half tones to build up the cover image in printed layers. I printed a silver first, then I printed white on top in different percentages, then I printed gold, then I printed another silver which goes on top of the whites and the gold and then I printed another white which then sits on top of the silver and the whites to create different layers and it’s fairly strange when you hold it in certain lights it actually does have a three dimensional quality.

The elements that I created – as a sort of visual language to carry across all the information – are the bold parts and it’s basically a very simple isometric shape – which is then exploded and then I built in Boris’ work too – so everything fits together.

The gold was originally going to be a flouro pink and underneath where the gold is – it was going to be two 100% hits of white with a fluorescent pink on top. But the fluorescent didn’t react well to the white printed on black. It needed to be printed on to bright white, so I ended up using gold. On the computer, the pink looked great – but when you get down to making something, things change and you learn stuff…

The artwork was a bitch. I was using percentages of colours – and then I was choosing the second white to try and work out what the percentage would be where the whites overlap.

CR: The catalogues and the gallery book are lavish affairs. Tell us about your relationship with the gallery – do you work closely with them on the layout of each publication? Do you have restrictions with budgets?
IC: Fiona will look at everything I do, while I’m doing it and in terms of the layout and the choice of work, we try and create a flow and sense of rhythm. If you were to give us both the same 50 images and asked us to pick eight, I bet you we’d both pick at least six of the same images. We’re really synchronised in our way of thinking. Fiona and Paul are both incredible – sometimes I feel that I’m given the freedom that they give their artists. They allow me, budget wise, to do what I’d like to do with the catalogues – they’re not restrictive or prescriptive in any way, either creatively or financially. I get to do my thing – which is great but that comes with a massive amount of responsibility because I have to deliver something exquisite because otherwise I’m failing – I’d be letting them down.


The cover for the catalogue for José Parlá’s Adaptation/Translation exhi­bi­tion [October 10 to November 8, 2008] is printed on cloth to show off a detail of one of the artist’s canvases. The book’s introduction features an essay on Parlá’s work by art historian Michael Betancourt, arranged far more traditionally than the intros of the other books. The catalogue has space not only for the works the artist showed in the exhibition, but also for numerous photographs taken by the artist on his extensive travels that relate to and inform his work

IC: Every book has its own unique set of challenges. My mission is to give these artists something that represents them completely but is a gift. When I give the guys their books, it’s an educated risk I take with the design and I hope they’re going to respond and that it will resonate with them in the correct way. So far, so good – but you really pay the price by taking that approach. What if they absolutely hate it?”

Every guy that I’ve given a book to – they look at it very quietly and go through the whole thing. And while every person has a totally different reaction, they always take their time and go through it very slowly. Anthony Lister said, after going through his catalogue “I didn’t know I warranted such a lovely colour.” For me that’s the moment that makes it worthwhile.

The Elms Lesters Painting Rooms book is published by the gallery and costs £175
Printer: Damiani (Elms Lesters Painting Rooms book). Moore (catalogues)

worldsdesign.co.uk
elmslesters.co.uk

Kudos

Kudos to the Jennie-O Turkey Store team, again, for snagging the iNOVA Grand Award in the Food and Beverage Websites category. I’m proud of the work our entire team did on this project and am happy to work with such a talented team every day!

Jennie-O Turkey Store: Grand winner.

Jennie-O web site

.chris{}

Little Chef’s Big Makeover

Last night, in the first installment of Big Chef takes on Little Chef, a new series on Channel 4, Heston Blumenthal, the culinary genius behind the Fat Duck restaurant, began a mission to revive the fortunes of ailing British roadside restaurant chain, Little Chef. If you missed the programme, there’s a rather good review of the programme by Susan Smillie on guardian.co.uk

To cut a long story short, Blumenthal has been given the Little Chef eatery in Popham to deliver experimental menus to find out what kind of food might entice the British public back to the restaurant. Read on to see images just sent in to us by design agency Praline who, in collaboration with interiors specialist Ab Rogers Design have transformed the frankly minging Little Chef at Popham into a spanky new clean and bright environment where customers can choose from Blumenthal’s menu. Will it be a success? Tune into Channel 4 tonight to pick up the story…


Is this what Little Chef CEO, Ian Pegler meant by “blue-sky thinking?”

CR Feb Issue


CR’s February cover, illustrated by Letman

The February issue of Creative Review is out on Wednesday 21 January, with features on Luke Hayman, Letman, Indian advertising, The Guardian’s new home, The Elms Lesters Painting Rooms and more…

Our Work section features first sight of the logo for Condé Nast’s forthcoming Love magazine, Dougal Wilson’s puppet-tastic video for Coldplay and Spin’s identity for Argentina’s PROA gallery

Features include an interview with Pentagram’s Luke Hayman in which he reveals the secret of his success – CR, of course (ahem)

A profile of Job Wouters, aka Letman, hand-lettering artist extraordinaire and brother of our former Creative Future, Roel. Job also designed our cover this month, which carries on our theme of basing the design around a listing of that month’s content. Also, our guest typeface this issue (as seen here) is Dessau Pro Stenzil Variant by Gábor Kóthay, distributed by Fountain

How The Guardian’s editorial design has grown, almost accidentally, into an all-encompassing visual language for the paper, which now includes signage at its new home (by Cartlidge Levene)

A look at why The Elms Lesters Painting Rooms, shunned by the mainstream gallery world, has given street art a home

And an examination of the role that advertising can play in ensuring that India doesn’t repeat the mistakes of the west in the face of growing consumerism

Plus, in Crit, we have all the usual discussion and comment including a look at advertising’s love of pain

And the all-important findings of our research into studio snacking and listening habits

Plus, subscribers will notice a change to Monograph this month. We are now using this rather beautiful Stephen Sultry Grey cover stock

Inside this month we feature Paul Belford’s collection of vintage Bollywood posters

And here’s the back cover with a key to the various pens that Letman used to design the front

It’s out on Wednesday 21 January. Enjoy.

Guardian Gives Shape To Obama’s Words

Expect Obama-mania in the media over the next couple of days as Inauguration Day approaches – ‘the nearest America will come to a coronation,’ as one wag has put it. In one of the more CR-relevant tie-ins, tomorrow’s Guardian G2 section will feature excerpts from a selection of speeches by Almost President Obama as interpreted by a mixture of designers and illustrators


Introducing it all is this cover by David Carson


Contributors inside include Sean Freeman


Peter Horridge


Jonathan Barnbrook


Mario Hugo


And Paula Scher

There is also to be a contribution from Alan Kitching but, as I write this, G2 art director Richard Turley has just emailed to say “we just received the Alan Kitching but it’s still wet (!) so can’t be scanned….. not sure what we’re going to do about it yet other than send the work experience into the toilets to hold it under the hairdryer… guess that demonstrates the kind of timescales we operate to in newspapers.” So that one may not appear.

Under Turley and deputy art director Jo Cochrane, the use of illustration in The Guardian’s G2 section has been a consistent highlight – not just for special projects such as this Christmas cover by Yulia Brodskaya

but also in the regular contributor pages. David Foldvari’s dark, sometimes menacing style is the perfect counterpart for the black humour of the regular Charlie Brooker column on Mondays

while the likes of David Hughes, Belle Mellor and a host of other illustrators – some established, some new – set G2 very much apart from its broadsheet competitors.

The New York Times has long been lauded for its use of illustration on the Op Ed pages. The Guardian’s G2 section deserves to be placed up alongside it for its consistent excellence.

Update: Looks like the work experience person did a good job with the dryer – here’s the Alan Kitching illustration in today’s paper

And the G2 cover

New Disc Packaging

I actually ordered a special edition version of Brian Eno and David Byrne’s Everything That Happens Will Happen Today album about four months ago – and it finally turned up last week… Here are some photos of the package – as well as a few other music packaging efforts that have caught our attention since getting back to work this year…

The Sagmeister-designed special edition of Everything That Happens Will Happen Today comes packaged in a round tin with a little house on it. Remove the lid (and a chip within plays the sound of some hammering followed by the sound of a creaking door) to reveal a grassy-looking disc containing the album. Underneath is a similar looking disc that contains the bonus material – a short film about the album by Hillman Curtis and four exclusive, bonus tracks – a miniature book, a small capsule (and a disclaimer stating that said pill contains calcium carbonate, the active ingredient found in common antacids, consult a doctor yadda yadda…), and a small dice:

And here are flat files of some the artwork from the miniature book, which is also the artwork that adorns the ‘normal’ edition of the album. Design by Sagmeister. Illustration by Stephan Walter).

Everything That Happens Will Happen Today - booklet image 1

Everything That Happens Will Happen Today - booklet title page

Everything That Happens Will Happen Today - booklet image 2

Everything That Happens Will Happen Today - booklet image 3

Everything That Happens Will Happen Today - booklet image 4

Andreas Döhring of Designliga created the artwork for Zombielicious, the new album from Zombie Nation. The screenprinted CD comes in a transparent jewel case with no booklet of artwork. Instead, the artwork visible on the front side consists of 2 layers: a white print on the surface of the jewel case (look closely!) and a screenprinted CD housed within. Nice. Label: UKW (ukw-records.com)

OK, this isn’t a commercial release but I wanted to show it because it’s great. It’s a compilation by designer Adam Faja, created as part of his contribution to an annual compilation CD swap organised by a group of graphic designers and which landed on my desk just before Christmas. Faja packaged a pink CD in a black floppy disk case and printed the tracklist in a typewriter font on lined card. Old school but gloriously tactile and nostalgic all at the same time.

Final Song is a compilation from label Get Physical. The concept of the comp is to approach various DJs and producers and ask them to nominate the song they’d most like to have played at their funeral and a brief explanation of their choice. Included are the selections of the likes of Gilles Peterson, DJ Hell, Laurent Garnier (who, perhaps surprisingly, selects a Radiohead track), David Holmes and Coldcut. As with all Get Physical releases, The Hort has art directed the packaging, with the cover sporting a rather nice cut paper illustration.

This is another non-commercial release but I thought it warranted inclusion as I rather like it. It’s a 4-DVD box set designed by studio-3’s Ryszard Bienert, for Polish artist Leszek Knaflewski as an appendix to the catalogue produced for his Crossroads versus Roundabouts exhibition which took place in Gallery Piekary in Poznan, Poland.

The 35 x 35 x 10 cm cardboard box has been screenprinted with the text – which contains a code only decipherable by the artist, according to Bienert. Inside the box, two sponges house and protect the four DVD discs, the bright colours of which relate to the four sections in the exhibition catalogue. Cardboard and sponge are also relevant material choices as these are the artist Knaflewski’s mediums of choice…

“The box has been produced in a limited amount of 50 and contains four different short films on separate DVDs,” explains Bienert. The box will be available for purchase through website 3-group.eu from mid January. Each box is signed by the artist.

Me, Myself and I


From designer Nicholas Felton’s recently-published Annual Report, documenting his 2008 in minute detail. Last year he travelled 38,524 miles. Average speed: 4.39 mph

Why do graphic designers find themselves so fascinating? As Nicholas Felton issues his latest Feltron Report for 2008, Michael Johnson examines the new wave of ‘me-projects’.

Over fifteen years ago a shock­wave was sent through graphics as designers put two fingers up to the ‘big idea’/’problem-solving’ tradition and turned to self-expression, writes Michael Johnson. They pro­claimed the processes they used almost as import­ant as the product itself, and, if they had the chance they’d be re-incarnated as concep­tual artists.


Detail from Felton’s page on music. Bradford Cox was his most-listened-to artist

Once the predictable flurry of hysteria from the tradi­tionalists died down, it became clear that genuine good could come from this and the savvier students and professionals took the ideas on board. So from Tomato’s early experi­ments to Carson’s typographic blitzkrieg, the profession received a useful kick up its rear end that knocked it out off its cosy woodcut, centred, brush­stroked axis.

How ‘self-initiated’ came to life varied, hugely. In the hands of students it veered into rampant self analysis: endless ‘embroidered-type-on-pillowcase’ projects on dreams and childhood memories; ‘mapping-my-journey-to-college’ posters, or impene­trable typographic essays as design donned Baudrillard’s intellectual beret for the first time.


Page from Felton’s 2007 Annual Report, documenting his subway
and taxi rides in New York

Practising professionals took it elsewhere – Paula Scher began her typographic ‘map’ paintings at about this time, Stefan Sagmeister intro­duced his naked body as the canvas for a series of self-mutilation projects. Daniel Eatock has now taken it to new heights, coming the closest to tipping out of design and into conceptual art. But recently ‘self-initiated’ has mutated into another strain, best described as ‘me-projects’. Taking Sagmeister as their cue, several designers have made themselves the epicentre of their work.

Consider Christopher Doyle, for example. Whilst holding down a day job in Sydney, he produced a set of design guidelines. OK, nothing new there – but the catch is that the guidelines are for himself. For the section on ‘black and white’, there he is, in black and white. He recently entered it into a design compe­­tition in Australia, with addi­tional material. The addi­tional material? Himself. Doyle stood by his brochure for a day whilst the judges passed judgement on his kerning (and his shoes).

Another classic example is Nicholas Felton’s annual report. For three years now we’ve studied how many miles he has run, how many emails and texts he has sent, which books he has read. In 2007 we found out when he met Sarah and when he turned thirty (but were they linked?). We know how much money gathered in his coin bucket, how many photos he has uploaded to Flickr, when he was attacked on the train, and so on.


Felton’s reading habits in 2007. He got through 20 books

He’s taken this to the logical conclusion by setting up a website with interactive designer Ryan Case (called Daytum) which encourages others to collect them-data (or would that be me-data?) and publish it too. So as I write, I can tell you that ‘Hannah J’ wishes she ‘could draw better, could read faster and could skateboard’. (It looks like her new year’s resolutions are sorted then).

Felton and Doyle’s link is that they are practising designers and have chosen known (and groan-inducing) aspects of life in graphics (the manual, the annual report) and turned them on their heads, away from dry instruc­tion to bizarre 21st century pastiche.

Why? When quizzed, Felton admits that ‘it satisfies a real curiosity that I have about my habits. Why is it a popular document? If there are numer­ous people out there who think it is fascinating and don’t even know me… imagine how fascinating I find it’. At first your reaction is ‘Oh please….’ but soon you are scouring the pages to see which was the most visited restaurant, his most-drunk beer: a sort of typographic Truman Show, authored by Truman himself.


An ‘average day’ in 2007 saw Felton listen to 69.2 songs, drink 1.7 cups
of coffee, send 15.9 office emails, and make 20.6 measurements for his Annual Report

Doyle acknowledges a long held desire to do more personal work but ‘never found the time’. He also admits that it was difficult: ‘I hadn’t counted on the self-examination. What this forced me to do was present myself, raw and true. I’ve always had issues with my weight, so it was it was a big thing for me to pose the way I did’.

The fact that Felton is now extending his ideas online comes as little surprise – it’s here that an up-and-coming designer, or blogger (or both) can grab their moment of fame. Some­times the level of profile achieved belies their youth: Craig Oldham’s projects gathering handwritten letters from designers and ‘12 in 12 things you might learn in your first year as a designer’ publication have been linked everywhere, but in reality he’s just two and a half years into his working life at The Chase in Manchester.


Handwritten letter from Michael Bierut for Craig Oldham’s project

Then there are the blogs themselves, perhaps the biggest me-projects of all. Many design blogs are still written by people whose work, when you follow the ‘portfolio’ link, is underwhelming, although it’s telling that recently the ranks of ‘designers that blog’ have been swelled by British veteran Mike Dempsey and über-gridnik Michael C Place. Their daily musings and observations are fascinating; even when they veer into the banal it still works, somehow.


Michael C Place/Build’s recently launched blog

But Felton is honest in appraising his me-projects: “I’ve been truly fortunate that it’s developed a following. As a result, I strive to make each year more special and more interesting than the last, and it has been an incredible promotional piece for my design practice.” Aha. Now we’re getting to it: it’s a promotional piece, and guess what – he also sells thousands of copies of it each year.

And what became of Doyle’s award entry? Well, he won. Perhaps these ‘me-projects’ are just another form of ‘me-promotion’, after all.

Michael Johnson is design director of johnsonbanks and editor of the studio’s Thought for the Week blog. This article appeared in the December issue of CR and also on Thought for the Week.

The Right Kind of Wrong


Installation view of The Right Kind of Wrong at Mother ad agency in London

Opening tomorrow night at Mother ad agency in London is an exhibition by graphic artist Anthony Burrill and product/furniture designer Michael Marriott.

The exhibition is held in the enormous entrance space of The Biscuit Building, where Mother’s offices are based, and this untraditional gallery space in fact influenced the way the work developed. “It’s quite a difficult space to show work in,” explains Burrill. “I thought it would be good to do something architectural. I’ve always like Michael Marriott’s work, so I asked him to work on it with me.”

The duo have created a freestanding sculptural piece, which Burrill describes as being an mixture of a “mobile shed” and a “chalet”. “It feels quite outdoorsy, as if it should be on a beach,” he continues. The sculpture is created using a range of materials, including rope, potted plants, and lots of wood, and also has laser cut details of the large text and simple graphic shapes that will be recognisable to fans of Burrill’s work.

“The text refers to the idea of truth,” continues Burrill. “It’s about the truth of materials, not disguising what things are made out of.” Conscious of the environmental times we live in, Burrill and Marriott set out to use as much of the materials as possible, and to waste nothing.

The theme of truth was also somewhat inspired by the exhibition’s setting in an advertising agency. “[The sculpture] feels a bit like a seige tower or Trojan Horse, and advertising doesn’t always deal with the truth all the time,” Burrill says. “There’s lots of layers to it.”

The Right Kind of Wrong is on show Mother until February 6. Visits must be booked by appointment – call 020 7739 8985. Burrill and Marriott’s sculpture will also be on show at this summer’s Village Fete at the V&A.

New Comment Policy On CR Blog

Or, Death To Trolls…

So far, on CR Blog, we have limited the moderation to anything that is openly offensive or potentially libellous. However, of late the quality of the debate here has been suffering from a rash of comments that really contribute nothing.

We don’t mind swearing, but to post a comment along the lines of “shit. the lot of them” or “that’s crap” does nothing to generate the type of informed debate that we hope the site can foster. We are all for criticism but, if you don’t like something, we want to know WHY.

So, as from now, we are instigating a more active moderation policy. Anything that, in the opinion of the moderators, is pointlessly abusive or adds nothing to the debate will be deleted.

And, as a reminder, here are the other criteria that we would ask you to observe:

“CR encourages comments to be short and to the point. As a general rule, they should not run longer than the original post. Comments should show a courteous regard for the presence of other voices in the discussion. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments that do not adhere to this standard.”

Thanks

Mobile Phones FINALLY Get Smart — Kinda

Apples iPhone has inspired a flood of next generation smartphones

Apple's iPhone has inspired a flood of next generation smartphones

It’s almost, as Yogi Bera would say, “deja vu all over again”. 7 years ago, after Apple first introduced the iPod, there was a rush of “iPod-killers” that flooded the market in order to compete. However, few of these devices ever caught-on long enough to realize any real commercial success and mount a serious challenge to the dominance of the iPod.

This time around, with the mobile market, Apple is something of a late entrant with its iPhone. In 2001, MP3 technology was still relatively new and no MP3 manufacturer had yet created a device — or desktop music management software — capable of establishing it in a dominent position. Not so with the mobile phone market. Last summer, when Apple first introduced the iPhone, it immediately faced stiff competition against entrenched and established manufacturers such as Motorola, Samsung, Sony Ericsson and Nokia.

That said, since the iPhone was released in July 2007, it has enjoyed a remarkable climb in market share, skyrocketing from 4% at the time of its debut to 23% to date. It therefore comes as no surprise that, once again, the popularity of Apple’s device has spawned numerous immitators from RIM/Blackberry’s Storm to LG’s Voyager.

While I don’t see an iPhone-killer in any of them, despite being a faithful iPhone user, I’m rooting for the imitators to do a better job of giving Apple a run for its money than the so-called iPod-killers did. Why? For the simple reason that a good, healthy competition will only end up quickening the pace of innovation and lowering the prices of the resulting products. Both not only good for consumers but also good for the future of mobile computing, which is the next, fastest-growing frontier in the digital space.

Graph courtesy of ChangeWave

Graph courtesy of ChangeWave

Of course, given the sad history of the manufacturers chasing Apple, I’m afraid I don’t have reason to be optimistic. And I’m ALWAYS optimistic! It’s tough for me to realistically expect a rapid pace of innovation to come from the same companies that, prior to the introduction of the iPhone, developed some of the most useless, unimaginative and uninteresting devices on the planet. That last bit is not hyperbole either. For years the United States mobile market has lagged significantly, and embarassingly, behind its European and Asian counterparts. I find it interesting that now that a popular competitor has entered the space, each of them has found a way to incorporate features that had been unheard of before, such as touchscreens and real web browsers.

And why are they content with merely immitating the iPhone rather than developing something truly unique, user-friendly and useful? If they are all content with merely copying and coming in second to the iPhone, it’s unlikely they’ll all of the sudden start truly innovating.

The digital future is at stake

Why is all this important? Why do I care if the others in the mobile market give Apple a run for its money, rather than watch it route the industry as it did with the iPod? Because this time the future of the Internet is at stake. A recent Pew Internet survey found that “the mobile device will be the primary connection tool to the internet for most people in the world in 2020″.  Also earlier this month, Opera Software announced in its latest State of the Mobile Web report that overall data traffic has increased 463% since last year.

Not entirely surprising. We now have mobile devices that are capable of doing things other than simply placing phone calls. The result is that we’re doing things with our mobile devices that we used to only be able to do with our desktop computers.

For those of us in the design field, we’re seeing clients begin to catch up very quickly as they ask for more ambitious mobile solutions to their business needs. This was hardly the case when useless WAP browsers run from archiac mobile operating systems ruled the market. Indeed one of the things that will make the iPhone so difficult to catch is the advantage it has, having developed a large ecosystem of innovators who write applications for the iPhone that extend its functionality far beyond Apple’s original functionality. Companies are beginning to see the advantages of empowering their customer/client bases and allowing them to connect with their brands wherever they are.

To be sure, Apple has never truly needed outside competitors to spark it’s internal culture of innovation. But it sure would be nice if others found religion and started really developing great products for once.

YEAH RIGHT!!!

.chris{}