Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind – more images

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

British photographers Hufton + Crow have sent us new images of the Dresden Museum of Military History, which reopened last month following an extension by New York architect Daniel Libeskind.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Libeskind drove a pointed steel and glass shard through the skin of the historic museum to create new galleries on five floors and a 30 metre-high rooftop viewing platform.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

When we originally published the story, many readers were outraged with the design, with one commentor suggesting it to be like a giant axe cutting through the building.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Critics also had a lot to say. Architecture journalist Rowan Moore described the building as both “breathtaking” and “breathtakingly dumb”, while critic Mary Lane compared it to “a piece of shrapnel freshly fallen from the sky” – read more about the critics opinions here.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Daniel Libeskind also recently completed a media centre for the University of Hong Kong – see our earlier story here and see all our stories about Libeskind here.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Another controversial museum we’ve published recently is the heavily criticised Museum of Liverpool – read more about that project here.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

See also: more stories about museums.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Photographers Hufton + Crow have shot a number of high-profile projects this year – see their photographs of the Serpentine Pavilion by Peter Zumthor and the Olympic Aquatics Centre by Zaha Hadid.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Critics’ reactions to Libeskind’s Military History Museum


Dezeen Wire:
 architecture critics have been offering their thoughts on Daniel Libeskind’s divisive Military History Museum in Dresden, which opened earlier this month.

The Observer‘s architecture critic Rowan Moore praised the spaces where the old museum meets the new addition but admonished the shard-like extension for its lack of functional space, stating: “The design’s weakness is its belief that sheer shape can speak on its own.”

In a review for The Wall Street Journal, Mary M. Lane described Libeskind’s intervention as “a piece of shrapnel freshly fallen from the sky” and outlines the architect’s motivations for working on the project, as a child of Holocaust survivors.

Writing in German publication Deutsche Welle, Ronny Arnold said that Libeskind’s renovation marks a new beginning and claims that “the museum is moving away from the mere presentation of war equipment and toward multidimensionality,” while Erin Huggins of The Local obtained a positive response to the building from museum spokesman Major Lars Berg, who said: “It’s an interesting combination of conventional components and something very progressive that one wouldn’t expect from the military.”

Libeskind’s design has had our readers up in arms – see the article and comments here and see all of our previous stories on Daniel Libeskind here.

Dezeenwire

Back to Dezeenwire »
Back to Dezeen »

Libeskind’s Military History Museum should be “more than a gesture”- The Observer


Dezeen Wire:
 in his latest review for The Observer architecture critic Rowan Moore criticises Daniel Libeskind‘s angular five-storey extension to the Military History Museum in Dresden, stating that ”something so large and conspicuous should surely be more than a gesture.”

Moore claims that the new intervention interacts successfully with the existing 1870s building but adds that some of the spaces are not as interesting as they should be and describes the projecting shard as “at once breathtaking, verging on the wonderful, and breathtakingly dumb.”

We had an amazing response when we published our story on the museum a few weeks ago. One reader described the design as “insensitive and inconsiderate,” while there was some praise including this comment: “Brave and bonkers. Excellent!” – see the story and comments here and all of our previous stories on Daniel Libeskind here

Dezeenwire

Back to Dezeenwire »
Back to Dezeen »

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

New York architect Daniel Libeskind has driven a pointed steel and glass shard through the heart of the war museum in Dresden, which reopens on October 14 after a 22-year closure.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

The five-storey triangular wedge extends the existing galleries of the Museum of Military History, making it the largest museum in Germany.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

The sharp tip of the structure points eastwards, to the source of firebombs dropped during the war, while a 30 metre-high rooftop viewing platform provides a view towards the city skyline in the west.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Inside the building, exposed concrete walls separate the new exhibition areas from the historic galleries.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Lectures and screening will take place inside the building’s auditorium.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Daniel Libeskind also recently completed a media centre for the University of Hong Kong – see our earlier story here and see all our stories about Libeskind here.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Photography is by Bitter Bredt.

Here’s some more information from Libeskind:


“It was not my intention to preserve the museum’s facade and just add an invisible extension in the back. I wanted to create a bold interruption, a fundamental dislocation, to penetrate the historic arsenal and create a new experience. The architecture will engage the public in the deepest issue of how organized violence and how military history and the fate of the city are intertwined.”—Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

The redesigned Dresden Museum of Military History is now the official central museum of the German Armed Forces. It will house an exhibition area of roughly 21,000 square feet, making it Germany’s largest museum.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Since its 1897 founding, the Dresden Museum of Military History has been a Saxon armory and museum, a Nazi museum, a Soviet museum and an East German museum. Today it is the military history museum of a unified and democratic Germany, its location outside the historic center of Dresden having allowed the building to survive the allied bombing campaign at the end of World War II.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

In 1989, unsure how the museum would fit into a newly unified German state, the government decided to shut it down. By 2001 feelings had shifted and an architectural competition was held for an extension that would facilitate a reconsideration of the way we think about war.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Daniel Libeskind’s winning design boldly interrupts the original building’s symmetry. The extension, a massive, five-story 140-ton wedge of glass, concrete and steel, cuts through the 135-year-old former arsenal’s structural order. A 98-foot high viewing platform provides breathtaking views of modern Dresden while pointing in the opposite direction toward the source of the fire-bombs, creating a dramatic space for reflection.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

The new façade’s openness and transparency contrasts with the opacity and rigidity of the existing building. The latter represents the severity of the authoritarian past while the former reflects the openness of the democratic society in which it has been reimagined.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

The interplay between these perspectives forms the character of the new Military History Museum.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

“The dramatic extension is a symbol of the resurrection of Dresden from its ashes. It is about the juxtaposition of tradition and innovation, of the new and the old. Dresden is a city that has been fundamentally altered; the events of the past are not just a footnote; they are central to the transformation of the city today.”- Daniel Libeskind

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

1. CHANGING PERSPECTIVE – The MHM offers different perspectives on German military history. The architecture, the new thematic exhibition and the redesigned permanent (chronological) exhibition represent both traditional and new forms of perception and expression. The juxtaposition of tradition and innovation, of old and new interpretations of military history, is the cornerstone of the new approach.

2. CULTURAL HISTORY OF VIOLENCE – The MHM offers visitors a history of the German military. But it goes beyond uniforms and weapons in its investigation state-controlled violence, offering new ways of assessing that history and the culture of violence that gave rise to it.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Click above for larger image

3. THE CENTRAL THEME IS THE HUMAN BEING – The central theme of the MHM’s architecture and exhibition design is an anthropological consideration of the nature of violence. The museum closely examines the fears, hopes, passions, memories, motivations and instances of courage, rationality and aggression that have precipitated violence and, all too often, war.

4. MUSEUM AS FORUM – In addition to presenting current and historical topics in special exhibitions and events, the MHM will host screenings, lectures and international symposia.

Dresden Museum of Military History by Daniel Libeskind

Click above for larger image

5. A NEW MUSEUM DISTRICT – Once a prosperous and heavily visited area, Dresden’s Albertstodt district, in which the museum is located, , has been deserted for some time. The new MHM will be the catalyst that turns the district into an international destination, a cultural center and a museum district. Made add’l change


See also:

.

Creative Media Centre
by Daniel Libeskind
Jewish Museum Extension
by Daniel Libeskind
Royal Ontario Museum
by Daniel Libeskind

Discovery by GPAC

Dresden studio GPAC have designed a children’s nursery for Bühlau in Dresden that looks like 13 eggs. (more…)