Critics review Rafael Viñoly’s “golden banana”


Dezeen Wire:
there has been mixed reaction from architecture critics to Rafael Viñoly’s firstsite visual arts centre in Colchester, dubbed the “golden banana” by some commentators.

Rowan Moore of The Observer writes harshly that the name of firstsite is apt as it is “great at first sight, but then less so,” criticising the building for the lack of suitable gallery spaces, while in The Guardian, Maev Kennedy describes the troubled and lengthly construction process.

The Telegraph’s Rupert Christiansen admires the local authority for backing the construction of such a high profile building but expresses doubts about its execution, while Simon Calder of The Independent is more positive, saying that the “brave new structure transcends its utilitarian surroundings” and could revitalise the image of the city.

Dezeenwire

Back to Dezeenwire »
Back to Dezeen »

Dezeen Screen: firstsite by Rafael Viñoly

Dezeen Screen: Firstsite by Rafael Viñoly Architects

Dezeen Screen: in this movie, architect Rafael Viñoly talks to Dezeen about firstsite, a visual arts centre wrapped in golden metal that he has completed in Colchester, England. Watch the movie here and see more images of the project in our earlier Dezeen story.

Firstsite by Rafael Viñoly Architects

Firstsite by Rafael Viñoly Architects

Architect Rafael Viñoly has completed a visual arts centre in Colchester, England, that is wrapped in polished golden metal.

Firstsite by Rafael Viñoly Architects

These copper-aluminium panels create diagonal stripes across the curved exterior walls of the single-storey gallery.

Firstsite by Rafael Viñoly Architects

The building is entitled Firstsite, as it is located on the site of one of the first Roman settlements in the UK.

Firstsite by Rafael Viñoly Architects

A restored mosaic embedded in the floor of one room will be the gallery’s only permanent exhibit.

Firstsite by Rafael Viñoly Architects

Visitors enter the crescent-shaped building through a tall glazed wall at one end.

Firstsite by Rafael Viñoly Architects

A reception here leads through to the galleries and to an auditorium lined with fabric diamonds and lengths of timber.

Firstsite by Rafael Viñoly Architects

Beyond the galleries, a café leads to an outdoor terrace.

Firstsite by Rafael Viñoly Architects

Other shiny metal-covered buildings from the Dezeen archive include a copper-clad hair salon and an office with a face of aluminium shingles.

Firstsite by Rafael Viñoly Architects

Photography is by Richard Bryant.

Here are some more details from the architects:


Firstsite, Colchester

The Building

The building plan is a modified crescent that wraps around a D-shaped eighteenth-century garden. It slopes upwards in line with the site topography, culminating in a monumental portico which frames the lobby with full-height glazing. Contemporary in both form and cladding, built on a steel frame and wrapped in TECU Gold (a copper-aluminum alloy), the building engages with the site’s axial geometry and the preexisting period architecture.

All construction took place at elevations above the Scheduled Ancient Monument datum line because buried archaeological artefacts precluded excavation. The building therefore floats on a concrete raft foundation which required no deep excavation. One of those artefacts, the Berryfield Mosaic, is set into the floor beneath protective glass, providing a glimpse of the history buried under the building. Internal levels work with the contours of the site; twelve different floor slab levels create subtle slopes that draw people through the building.

An interior promenade carries visitors from the vast entrance space through to the auditorium, University and Mosaic spaces, learning areas and main exhibition spaces, ending up at the café restaurant, MUSA. The curved form of the building creates the sense of a journey that allows visitors to encounter artwork as they walk through the building. The café restaurant at the end of this promenade provides social space lit by overhead clerestory windows; it includes an outdoor terrace which overlooks the adjacent gardens. Administrative space and galleries aligned on the inside arc of the building feature wide glazing that provides natural light and views of the adjacent eighteenth-century garden. Sensitive landscaping animates the open garden spaces, including artwork designed by artist Simon Periton installed September 2011.

In accordance with the design mandate to turn the traditional white cube gallery inside-out, extensive natural lighting and clear internal orientation is maintained by preserving sightlines to the outdoors. Floor-level strips of windows animate the design by revealing to visitors in the garden the movement of people inside, while also providing diffused light to the interior; clerestory windows give further natural light.

The Site

The site, near the town centre of one of Britain’s first Roman settlements, sits on Scheduled Ancient Monument land, with an intact Roman wall defining the southern boundary. Because archaeological remains are scattered throughout the site, maximum loads on the ground and a no-dig policy, the building had to impose a minimum load on the existing topography.

As the first project in the revitalisation of Colchester’s historic St Botolph’s Quarter, firstsite anchors the long-term development plan of an underused district. Rafael Viñoly Architects PC proposed a number of revisions to the original St Botolph’s Quarter master plan, all of which were subsequently adopted. The proposed building site was moved eastward, away from the town centre, redistributing the area of redevelopment. This faciliated a more sensitive relationship between the building and the historic assets of Colchester; specifically, by preserving the character of the north-south Queen Street/St Botolph’s Street corridor, which connects the Colchester Castle Museum (to the north) and the Colchester Town train station (to the south) with a gently curving street of historical buildings.

The new location situates the building in a park, creating new public space as an appropriate setting for a cultural destination. (A bus station was relocated to accommodate this new construction.) The site is now directly south of the eighteenth-century Grade I Listed East Hill House, which firstsite faces across a D-shaped garden that lends it its crescent shape, and whose Grade II gothic folly was separated from the house in the mid twentieth century by the construction of a bus station. Views from the museum to the first-century Roman wall emphasise the historical importance of this ancient structure. Other prominent nearby structures include Grade II Listed twelfth century St James’s Church and the Minories Art Gallery, the latter a red-brick Georgian townhouse that served as firstsite’s original home, and which has been a gallery since the 1950s.

Spaces

The auditorium is clad internally with diamond-patterned, suede-like acoustic fabric and overlapping European cherry timber shells. It will be used for film screenings, performances, lectures and presentations. Situated behind the Entrance space, it leads visitors on to the main gallery areas which are defined by a varied materials palette of an ammonia-fumed oak floor and angled/curving plasterboard walls. The Foundation for Sport and the Arts Gallery, a climate-controlled, museum-quality hanging space, is accompanied by many adaptable display opportunities. The flexible spatial configuration promotes interaction between visitors and artists, as spaces can be opened up to the galleries to encompass learning, artist residencies, and exhibitions. Programmed spaces are clustered, with the learning spaces in one area, conference and administration facilities in another, the galleries are concentrated near the centre of the building, and the café restaurant MUSA at the far eastern end.

The newly restored Berryfield Roman Mosaic is located at the heart of the firstsite building. Dating from around AD200, the mosaic was unearthed in 1923 by a local tenant on the site where firstsite now stands. The Mosaic originally formed part of the dining room floor of a wealthy Roman townhouse. After 80 years in Colchester Castle, the Mosaic has been painstakingly restored and returned to its rightful home, as firstsiteÊs only permanent exhibit. Its design consists of a central rose motif surrounded by four panels depicting sea monsters chasing Dolphins.
The Mosaic, which has been carefully cleaned and now benefits from a new lightweight backing, is displayed horizontally in a case embedded into the floor of the building.

MUSA, firstsiteÊs contemporary café restaurant will be open every day to gallery visitors and the general public. Award winning chef Paul Boorman will lead a talented young team in the kitchen to create an innovative modern British menu, applying cutting-edge techniques to traditionally inspired dishes. Open 8am ! 6pm Monday to Saturday and 10am ! 5pm on Sunday, diners can enjoy a drink at the bar and eat inside or on the terrace. On Sundays, there will be an all-day brunch menu available, and on Thursday, Friday and Saturday evenings, MUSA will open from 7pm as a destination restaurant for Colchester and North Essex.


See also:

.

Carrasco Airport
by Rafael Viñoly
Stem Cell Building
by Rafael Viñoly
Cleveland Museum
by Rafael Viñoly

Competition: five copies of Rafael Viñoly Architects to be won

competition Rafael Vinoly Architects

Competition: we have teamed up with Rafael Viñoly Architects to give away five copies of their new monograph, written by Rafael Viñoly and critic Philip Jodidio.

competition Rafael Vinoly Architects

Carrasco International Airport , Montevideo, Uruguay. Photo copyright Daniela Mac Adden.

The hardcover book contains photographs, sketches and renderings from Viñoly’s earliest projects to the firm’s most recent work.

competition Rafael Vinoly Architects

Boston Convention and Exhibition Center, Boston, USA. Photo copyright Brad Feinknopf.

Read all our stories about Rafael Viñoly Architects on Dezeen »

competition Rafael Vinoly Architects

Tokyo International Forum. Tokyo, Japan. Photo copyright Kawasumi Architectural Photography.

To enter this competition email your name, age, gender, occupation, and delivery address and telephone number to competitions@dezeen.com with “Rafael Viñoly Architects” in the subject line. We won’t pass your information on to anyone else; we just want to know a little about our readers.

Read our privacy policy here.

competition Rafael Vinoly Architects

Center for Science and Computation, Bard College, New York, USA. Photo copyright Brad Feinknopf.

Competition closes 12 July 2011. Five winners will be selected at random and notified by email. Winners’ names will be published in a future edition of our Dezeenmail newsletter and at the bottom of this page. Dezeen competitions are international and entries are accepted from readers in any country.

The following is from the press release:


Rafael Viñoly Architects
By Rafael Viñoly and Philip Jodidio
Publication Date: May 2011

The definitive monograph highlighting the global works of this leading contemporary architect.

For nearly half a century Rafael Viñoly has been driven by the belief that the responsibility of architecture is to elevate the public realm. While his early work in Argentina transformed the landscape of the country, his first major international projects – the John Jay College of Criminal Justice in New York and the International Forum in Tokyo – established Viñoly as a global presence in architecture, whose buildings sustain a structural originality that transcends passing fads. This monograph features a chronological sampling of Viñoly’s best work in the United States, Latin America, Europe, Asia, Africa and the Middle East. The large and small-scale projects encompass courthouses, private residences, athletic facilities, performing arts centres, museums and educational buildings. Illustrated with photographs, plans and drawings, and accented by Viñoly’s personal reflection on his career, this volume brings together the achievements of one of today’s most internationally acclaimed architects.

The Author

Rafael Viñoly was born in Uruguay and by the age of twenty was founding partner of Estudio de Arquitectura, which would become one of the largest design studios in Latin America. In 1983 he founded Rafael Viñoly Architects PC, a New York based firm that now has offices in London, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Chicago, and Abu Dhabi. Philip Jodidio has published numerous books on contemporary architecture, including Architecture: Art and Architecture: Nature (both by Prestel). He lives in Grimentz, Switzerland.

Subscribe to our newsletter, get our RSS feed or follow us on Twitter for details of future competitions.

150-colour-dezeen-books-450.jpg

Buy this book and others at the Dezeenbooks store
(in association with amazon.co.uk)

More competitions »
Back to Dezeen »

Stem Cell Building at UCSFby Rafael Viñoly Architects

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

This medical research building at the University of California in San Francisco by Rafael Viñoly Architects projects out from a forest hillside, supported on steel truss stems that fan upwards from the ground.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

Designed to accomodate 125 individual biology laboratories for scientists studying stem-cell treatment, the building has one laboratory floor split into four levels, which step down half a storey at a time as they descend the hill.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

Offices are located above each level, connected by a stepped circulation route on the exterior of the building which also bridges across to the adjacent medical centre.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

The building has south-facing glazing to maximise natural light into the laboratories and offices.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

More from Rafael Viñoly Architects on Dezeen »

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

More medical buildings on Dezeen »

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

The following is from the architects:


Stem Cell Building at UCSF by Rafael Viñoly Architects:

San Francisco, California: Rafael Viñoly Architects’ design of the Ray and Dagmar Dolby Regeneration Medicine Building at the University of California, San Francisco has been completed.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

The project is targeting LEED Gold certification. DPR Construction served as the design-build contractor and the Smith Group served as executive architect. The University held a grand opening celebration of the building on February 9, 2011.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

Located on a steeply sloping urban hillside, the Dolby regeneration medicine building presented the design team a unique challenge: executing a horizontal structure on an uneven site.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

RVA responded by creating a beautifully sinuous, serpentine building that makes use of every foot of available space.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

The main floor functions as one continuous laboratory divided into four split levels, each stepping down a half-story as the building descends the forested hillside slope, and each level is topped by an office cluster and a grass roof with wildflowers and plants.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

Exterior ramps and stairs, taking advantage of the temperate climate, provide continuous circulation between all levels, and the facility connects to three nearby research buildings and UCSF Medical Center via a pedestrian bridge.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

The building structure is supported by steel space trusses springing from concrete piers, minimizing site excavation and incorporating seismic base isolation to absorb earthquake forces.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

Inside the building, the transitions between the split levels are designed as hubs of activity. Break rooms and stairs located at these interfaces increase the potential for chance interaction – a goal for promoting a cross-pollination of ideas among the scientists –  and interior glazing maximizes visual connectivity between the lower labs and the upper offices.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

To further promote collaboration, the laboratories occupy a horizontal open-floor plan, with a flexible, custom-designed casework system that enables the rapid reconfiguration of the research program.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

Abundant south-facing glazing fills the open laboratories and offices with natural light and views of the wooded slope of Mount Sutro nearby.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

Green roof terraces impart environmental benefits and an outdoor amenity for building occupants and campus community.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

Visible from surrounding campus buildings’ upper floors, the terraces create a welcoming transitional space where the dense campus meets the forest.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

The Ray and Dagmar Dolby Regeneration Medicine Building is the headquarters for The Eli and Edythe Broad Center of Regeneration Medicine and Stem Cell Research at UCSF, which extends across all UCSF campuses.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

The Center encompasses 125 labs made up of scientists exploring the earliest stages of animal and human development.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

The goal of these studies is to understand how disorders and diseases develop and how they could be treated based on the knowledge of, and use of, stem cells and other early-stage cells.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

The Institute’s mission is to translate basic research findings to clinical research and on to patient care.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects

Scientists in the Institute will work closely with clinical researchers at UCSF Medical Center, located nearby, to translate discoveries into therapeutic strategies.

Stem-Cell-Building-at-UCSF-by-Rafael-Viñoly-Architects


See also:

.

United States Senate
by Rafael Viñoly
Cleveland Museum of Art by Rafael ViñolyMedical Centre
by Doblee Architects